Official Inkheart Movie trailer

Just found this today. I love this book! And the movie looks like it might be pretty good - who doesn't like Brendan Frasier and Helen Mirren? You can tell the plot is a little different from the book, but I'm excited anyway. Good story. Has anyone else read it? Cat, I think you have -right?

Practical Magic discussion

Hi Everyone! Sorry I'm posting so late, but at least it is still September. I've been out of town for a family funeral and life has been pretty crazy. I hope you all enjoyed "Practical Magic."

Questions
1.) What did you think of the book in comparison to the movie?

2.) Who was your favorite character?

3.) What did you think of Alice Hoffman's writing style? (And tell us if you've read any other books by her.)

4.) Do you have a favorite scene from the book?

My answers:
1.) I read several reviews where people said this is the only book they've read where the movie was better. I hate to admit that about a book, but I do see their point. But to standby books, I think this story stands on it's own as a book and as a movie. They changed a few of the characters and plot for the movie, so you can enjoy both as unique. (The daughters are younger in the movie, they all live at the aunts house, etc..) However, I will say that I probably will only read the book once, but I could watch the movie multiple times.

2.) I wish we saw more of the aunts in the book! I really wanted to read more about them. The nieces got on my nerves, but I really liked the daughters. Especially the youngest - although I can't remember her name now.

3.) This is the only Alice Hoffman book I've read to date. I enjoy how she starts each chapter of Practical Magic with a little piece of magic folklore and then slowly weaves it into the storyline. I think it was effective in creating a place where magic feels like it could exist and still be a story in a modern day.

4.) I liked any time the youngest daughter (Was her name Callie?) notices weird things about the lilac bush - like seeing the dead guy under it, having the toad bring her the ring, or knowing he is the reason for the tension in her house.

Too Many Good Books!

The votes are in and our book for October is the Five Love Languages. We'll go with the adult one (there's one on children as well but once you read the first it's basically the same thing). There are so many good books out there. It's hard to choose just one, so thanks for your help ladies! Looking forward to the September discussion.

Practical Magic

Happy September!

I chose a book that I guess should be done in October, but oh well. This month we'll read "Practical Magic" by Alice Hoffman. I've wanted to read it since I found that it was the inspiration for the movie with Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman. Lisa previewed it for us and there are a few pages you might want to skip, but hopefully we will enjoy it otherwise.

If you are in Savannah, this is also the book we are doing for our on-site book club.

Book choice

I cannot remember which month is mine, I believe it is November? I am still trying to decide my choice, I have a number 1 choice and need to do more research to see if it is appropriate.

quick vote

I have a few ideas for books for October and thought I would gather some opinions.

1: The Five Love Languages Chapman
2: The Secret Garden
3: To Kill a Mockingbird
4: Where the Red Fern Grows
5: A Good Earth

I know there are lots of good books out there, but these are a few on my list that I thought might make for a good read. Leave your vote~

The Man of the Forest Discussion

This is a few days early, I know, but I will be a little busy in the next few days and didn't want to forget, so if you haven't finished yet, no worries.

I hope you all loved The Man of the Forest as much as I love it. I read it for the first time when I was ten, and even though I probably missed a lot, I was instantly drawn into this story. I loved that it was about sisters, romance, and good vs. evil, etc. Every time I read it, I get more from it. Here are my questions, and when you answer them, feel free to add one of your own :).

What was your most memorable or favorite scene from the book?

Even though there were so many great ones to choose from, I loved so many, but the scene where Al comes to get the girls in paradise Park and asks Bo about the cowboy "Las Vegas," was one of my favorites. I just loved how this strong cowboy was so shy and at a loss, and how funny the whole situation seemed to outsiders. In fact, I liked most every scene with this cowboy in it :).

Nineteen of Grey's westerns are set in the twentieth century. He mixes contemporary events such as World War I, revolutions in Mexico, large-scale dam construction, and increasing automobile use with traditional frontier elements. He suggests not only that the frontier was intact in some places but also that it could be safely visited because heroes resided there to protect innocent travelers (ZGWS). Part of this, he does through his cowboys like Carmichael, who lived most of their life as gunslingers standing up to evil. (You especially see this in his book Nevada) Helen always seemed to have a problem with this violence, but do you think this type of action was necessary for the settlement of the West?

Granted, I didn't live during this time, but from all I have ever read about it, if there hadn't been those strong heroes who were willing to sacrifice everything to stand up for the right, then settling the West would have been much harder. And although I think it is sad it had to come to bloodshed, I feel it was necessary.

Zane Grey wrote fantastic descriptions of the West, and his descriptions of western landscapes rank among the most striking ever written and are still valued for their ability to capture the character of places. What did you think of his descriptions?

Every time I read a Zane Grey novel I find myself longing for my home in the West. I was born in Arizona, raised wandering the mountains and deserts of Nevada, and spent many years in Idaho and Utah. I feel like his descriptions are very authentic and remind me of times I have been out in the wilderness and really felt close to nature. I especially loved how close to nature they got in Paradise Park. Although I don't think I could have lived that lonely life, I can appreciate it.

That said, there are many times when I completely skim over the descriptions, because as good as they are, there are a lot of them. I do think his descriptions were perfect for the time when there was no TV, Internet, and limited travel, and so this was the only way most people would experience these places.

Bo and Helen adjusted to their new life in the West very differently. Which of them do think you would most be like and why? Do you think either of their actions was better than the other?

As much as I think I would probably be like Helen - I think too much - I wish I could be free like Bo. Although Bo got into trouble at times because of her quick adjustment into their new life, I love how easily she let herself become one with the lifestyle and the place. I think they both did their best, but I think sometimes Helen let her sensibilities get in the way of letting people do what needed to be done.

Back on track!

Phew, the summer travels are over and I am back on track. I'm excited to share my readings. I have been reading a book called "A Thomas Jefferson Education" It is fantastic. (I am hoping to be able to use this method to homeschool my children this year) Anyway, it talks about learning through the classics and challenges the way you read. I decided to tackle Wuthering Heights. I know I should have read it ages ago, but I don't particularly like depressing stories. Though it is not a favorite, I found it entertaining and really can't stand Heathcliff. I feel sorry for him to have had so little love shown him and to have immersed all his love in one person. He missed out on what could have been a very joyful life! I have also just finished Old Yeller. What a great book. I am planning on comparing it to Where the Red Fern Grows and Because of Wynn Dixie. It's fun to go back and hit the children's classics occasionally. They have so much to offer and I needed to learn a few things. Lastly I am finishing Mothering With Spiritual Power and have loved it. What a great book. I think I really needed it. I hope you have all had a super summer. I'm excited to read a Zane Grey!

Anna Karenina for July

This was my book for the month, and it literally took a month to read, at 749 pages. I think that the story was a great one, semi sad ending though. I kind of felt that Anna even though she followed her heart and did what she felt was best for herself, that she deserved the paranoia and heartache. Her ending was the only one that would have fit in the time the book was written and the situation she was in. I was very happy about Kity and Levin's ending it was perfect. I didn't love all the politically conversations though they were boring and a bit confusing for me. I liked the book and although I wouldn't read it again since it occupied half my summer; I would recommend it to others. It is a classic and well written.

What I read in July . . .

I know we didn't have a July book, and so we were all going to share what we read this month, so I am sharing . . .

The Changeling Sea, by Patricia McKillip: I really enjoyed this creative fantasy. I especially loved the main character, Peri (short for Periwinkle). She was strong, loyal, and did not give up on life, although all those she loved had been lost to the sea in one way or the other.

The only thing that I didn't like as much was that the romance in it was a little disappointing. Although Peri was believable in her love, it was harder for me to buy the Prince's performance. And although his reactions were understandable given the story, it didn't stop me from wanting him to show her more affection.

All and all, a very sweet and enchanting read about magic, love, and saying good bye.

PS. I can't wait to hear what you all read. Oh, and have fun reading our August book :).